Santa Ana, CA
Down 14 points with less than five minutes remaining, Mater Dei appeared headed toward another difficult loss in a season that had already tested one of California's most successful high school football programs. Instead, freshman quarterback Paytyn Guess delivered a finish that will be remembered for years to come, leading the Monarchs to a stunning 36-35 victory over longtime rival St. John Bosco on Friday night at Santa Ana Stadium. Mater Dei scored two touchdowns in the final four minutes before converting a two-point attempt with just 7.5 seconds remaining to complete the comeback. Sophomore tight end Tyler Fritz secured the decisive conversion, giving the Monarchs their fifth consecutive victory over the Braves and extending their winning streak to four games. The victory improved Mater Dei to 8-2 overall and 4-1 in Trinity League play, while St. John Bosco dropped to 7-3 and 3-2 in league competition. With both programs preparing for the Southern Section Division I playoffs, Friday's matchup delivered another memorable chapter in one of the nation's biggest high school football rivalries.
The matchup featured two nationally ranked programs looking to finish the regular season with momentum after experiencing unexpected setbacks earlier in the year. Mater Dei entered Friday ranked No. 18 nationally by MaxPreps, while St. John Bosco held the No. 11 position despite beginning the season as the nation's top-ranked team. Both programs had suffered two losses entering the contest, creating additional pressure in a rivalry that has frequently determined league championships and postseason positioning. Mater Dei had defeated St. John Bosco in each of their previous four meetings, including a 36-31 victory during the 2025 regular season. The Monarchs had also defeated the Braves in the Southern Section Division I championship games in 2023 and 2024, adding to the recent history between the two programs. With Santa Margarita already positioned to capture the Trinity League championship, Friday's contest carried major implications for second place and the upcoming playoff seedings.
Mater Dei wasted little time taking advantage of an early opportunity as St. John Bosco quarterback Koa Malau'ulu lost possession on the opening play of the game. The turnover immediately placed the Monarchs in position to strike, and Guess capitalized with a 19-yard touchdown run to give Mater Dei an early 7-0 advantage. St. John Bosco responded behind Malau'ulu, who helped the Braves move downfield before scoring on a 9-yard rushing touchdown to even the contest. The Monarchs answered through the passing game as Guess connected with Gavin Honore for a 23-yard touchdown reception, restoring Mater Dei's seven-point lead. St. John Bosco continued finding ways to respond, with running back Maliq Allen breaking free for a 64-yard touchdown on a short pass to tie the game at 14. The back-and-forth opening half demonstrated the offensive talent on both sidelines as neither program was able to establish complete control.
With the game tied at 14, Mater Dei benefited from several costly St. John Bosco penalties that helped extend opportunities for the Monarchs' offense. The Braves were penalized for sideline interference and taunting, while a facemask penalty erased a recovered fumble that could have shifted momentum in their favor. Mater Dei eventually put together a nine-play scoring drive that relied entirely on its rushing attack, keeping the St. John Bosco defense on the field while moving steadily toward the end zone. Guess capped the possession with a 4-yard touchdown run, giving the Monarchs a 21-14 advantage heading into halftime. The freshman quarterback had already accounted for three touchdowns during the opening two quarters, demonstrating his ability to contribute both through the air and on the ground. Although St. John Bosco had shown flashes of offensive success, its early turnover and penalties helped Mater Dei maintain control entering the second half.
The momentum changed dramatically after halftime as St. John Bosco began taking advantage of its passing attack behind Malau'ulu. The Braves opened the third quarter with a scoring drive that included a 27-yard completion to Jacob Reid, helping move the offense into position to challenge Mater Dei's defense. Malau'ulu then connected with Trevon Bates for a 27-yard touchdown pass, tying the game at 21 with 8:48 remaining in the period. The score marked the beginning of a dominant stretch for St. John Bosco, which continued applying pressure as Mater Dei struggled to sustain offensive possessions. Following another unsuccessful Monarchs drive and a short punt, the Braves quickly returned to work through the air. Malau'ulu connected with multiple receivers before finding sophomore Kuika Moaalii for a touchdown in the back corner of the end zone, giving St. John Bosco its first lead of the evening at 28-21 with 3:50 remaining in the third quarter.
St. John Bosco's defense played an important role in the second-half turnaround, preventing Mater Dei from establishing the offensive rhythm it had enjoyed during the opening two quarters. Before the Monarchs began their late comeback, they had managed just 37 yards on 15 offensive plays during the second half. The Braves continued building on their advantage in the fourth quarter, using a 55-yard scoring drive to extend their lead to two possessions. A 47-yard completion to Moaalii helped set up the opportunity before Allen finished the drive with a 4-yard touchdown run. With 4:35 remaining in regulation, St. John Bosco held a commanding 35-21 advantage after scoring 21 unanswered points. Given the Braves' defensive success throughout the second half, Mater Dei appeared to be running out of opportunities to reverse the result.
Facing a 14-point deficit with time running out, Mater Dei turned to Guess and its passing attack in search of a response. The freshman quarterback quickly delivered, connecting with Honore for a 55-yard touchdown that brought the Monarchs within seven points with 3:26 remaining. The score ended St. John Bosco's run of 21 unanswered points and gave Mater Dei renewed momentum heading into the final minutes. With the Braves still holding a 35-28 advantage, the Monarchs needed their defense to create another opportunity for the offense. St. John Bosco managed to pick up a first down on its ensuing possession, but Mater Dei eventually forced a punt and regained possession at its own 28-yard line with just 55 seconds remaining. With no timeouts available, Guess faced the challenge of moving the Monarchs downfield against a defense that had controlled much of the second half.
Guess wasted little time creating an opportunity, connecting with fellow freshman Tristan Brown for a 49-yard completion that immediately moved Mater Dei into scoring position. The connection highlighted the chemistry between the two young players, who had known each other since childhood and were now competing together in one of the nation's biggest high school football rivalries. With the clock continuing to run, Guess directed the offense toward the end zone as the Monarchs searched for the touchdown they needed to extend the game. Facing third down from the St. John Bosco 12-yard line, Guess delivered a pass toward Brown, who elevated over the defense and secured the touchdown with 7.5 seconds remaining. The score brought Mater Dei within one point at 35-34, leaving head coach Raul Lara with a decision between attempting an extra point to force overtime or going for the victory. Lara elected to keep his offense on the field, trusting his freshman quarterback to deliver one more play with the game on the line.
On the decisive two-point conversion, Guess looked toward Fritz, who moved across the formation and found an opening in the St. John Bosco defense. The sophomore tight end briefly bobbled the pass before securing possession, completing the conversion and giving Mater Dei a 36-35 lead with just 7.5 seconds remaining. The successful play completed a remarkable comeback after the Monarchs had trailed by two touchdowns less than four minutes earlier. Guess finished with three passing touchdowns and two rushing scores, accounting for all five of Mater Dei's touchdowns in the victory. Brown contributed four receptions for 104 yards, including the crucial 49-yard gain and the final touchdown that positioned Mater Dei for the winning conversion. Honore also delivered two important touchdown receptions, including the 55-yard score that sparked the late comeback, while Fritz's conversion ultimately provided the deciding points.
Despite the defeat, St. John Bosco received a strong performance from Malau'ulu, who threw for more than 350 yards and three touchdowns while adding a rushing score. The Braves' passing attack created several explosive opportunities, with Reid, Bates, Moaalii, and Allen contributing to an offense that scored 21 unanswered points during the second half. St. John Bosco's defense also produced four sacks, including two from Kekoa Peko, helping limit Mater Dei's offense for much of the final two quarters. However, the Braves were unable to prevent Guess from delivering two late scoring drives, allowing the Monarchs to complete one of the most dramatic comebacks in the rivalry's history. Mater Dei's victory secured second place in the Trinity League and strengthened its postseason positioning, while St. John Bosco entered the playoffs looking to recover from another narrow loss to its longtime rival. With both teams preparing for the Southern Section Division I postseason, Friday's contest served as another reminder of how quickly momentum can change when two of California's premier football programs meet.
Final Score: Mater Dei 36 - St. John Bosco 35
For more pictures, head over to our photo gallery.
Pictures taken by: Kennedy Velasco - @kennnchapo & Pakela Wheeler - @pakela._